Recent Comments by jwray subscribe to this feed

Tom Mabe funny phone call
He would only get in trouble if the telemarketer complained to the cops. I'm sure the jury would make an exception in this situation, though.


written by jwray  | 7 hours 53 minutes 24 seconds ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

Obama and McCain: What do we do about evil?
"Does evil exist, and if it does, do we ignore it, do we negotiate with it, do we contain it, do we defeat it?"

That's such a simple-minded question. The word evil connotes a conflation of many separate problems. Most of these problems are far more complicated than simply being susceptible to McCain's brute force. You can't negotiate with an abstract staw-man, but you can negotiate with most people who have done harm. Obama gave a satisfactory answer.


written by jwray  | 14 hours 31 minutes 31 seconds ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)

Spaghetti Cat makes a mysterious TV appearance
Someone from 4chan probably hax0red that TV network for the lulz.


written by jwray  | 16 hours 17 minutes 29 seconds ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)

Harry Potter And The Half Blood Prince Official Trailer
I love that book! This trailer makes my skin tingle.


written by jwray  | 1 day 1 hour 12 minutes ago | CH
 2  | flag spam (0)

Harry Potter And The Half Blood Prince Official Trailer
*doublepromote


written by jwray  | 1 day 1 hour 21 minutes ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

Copyright regime vs. civil liberties
*promote


written by jwray  | 2 days 5 hours 56 minutes ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

Adorable Snoring Kitten
15 seconds of that is enough cuteness for a day. I don't think I can handle the full minute.


written by jwray  | 2 days 15 hours 50 minutes ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)

Fox News Special Report - "Hacker Gangs"
*promote


written by jwray  | 3 days 6 hours 11 minutes ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

In The 21st Century Nations Don't Invade Others Nations
LOL, hypocrisy


written by jwray  | 4 days 14 hours 30 minutes ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)

Milton Friedman on Education
How would we know, with your proposed system, if the externalities overshadow, and relegate the educational methodology to statistical irrelevance?


Stratify the statistics. For example, for several ranges of scores, compute the average improvement over X years for students who entered the school in that range of scores. This would expose whether the school specializes in catering to a particular range of students.



written by jwray  | 5 days 21 hours 28 minutes ago | CH
 1  | flag spam (0)

Obama - "It's like these guys take pride in being ignorant"
Prisons guarantee that their inmates won't starve to death, and provide inmates with basic medical care. It seems to me that, to avoid providing an incentive for poor people to commit crimes, law abiding citizens should get a better deal than criminals. If there is no welfare, then the poorest of the poor are practically rewarded for committing crimes, by being sent to prison where they will get free food, shelter, and medical care. That is why there should still be a welfare system.


written by jwray  | 6 days 8 hours 47 minutes ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

Copyright regime vs. civil liberties
*promote


written by jwray  | 6 days 23 hours 49 minutes ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

Armed store robber taken down by customer in Tulsa
The guy in this video had a 25 year sentence in 1987, so he must have got out on parole at least 5 years early.


written by jwray  | 6 days 23 hours 56 minutes ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

Vice President Cheney Implicated In Forgery
>> ^Raverman:
If they can try to impeach clinton for a blowjob, How many Lies from the administration are needed before someone does something?


The thing is, they weren't under oath when they lied, because everybody in the Bush Administration refuses to testify under oath, even if it means ignoring a congressional subpoena. And only a few democratic congressmen have the balls to support handing out the proper punishment for refusing to testify, which is a contempt of congress citation. There are plenty of other grounds for impeachment, though.




written by jwray  | 1 week ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)

Milton Friedman on Education
Taking tests in a skill in and of itself and doesn't accuretly judge if those things were learned or not is what I am saying.

That hypothesis is unfalsifiable by definition. I mean how do you know how well the test results match up with some notion of "real ability", except by comparing those results to the results of some other tests?

Yes, "not everyone learns the same things". But if you put a random sampling of vocabulary on the test, you still can still get a good estimate of a student's vocabulary. The larger the sample, the narrower the confidence interval, of course. Random sampling is a bit more complicated in other subjects, but it still works.

Those "test taking skills" are nothing but elementary deductive reasoning (in the case of multiple choice, and almost all standardized tests are multiple choice). If a student doesn't comprehend that sort of deductive reasoning, that is a deficiency in itself that will have negative effects reaching far beyond test-taking. Likewise the ability to stay calm and think clearly under pressure is a skill that has uses far beyond test-taking and should be considered just as important as mastery of the subject.

Though test taking skills are helpful in getting high scores, they are not sufficient for getting high scores on a test. If you know the subject perfectly, you do not even need to use elimination or reductions on multiple choice questions, and you get a high grade regardless of test-taking skills. If you know test-taking skills perfectly, but don't know the subject, you're still getting a low grade on the test. So the issue you raise doesn't make these tests useless, it just makes them a bit less accurate.

The "tests don't really measure knowledge" mantra is, I think, comforting wishful thinking coming from parents of underachieving students.

There are intangible aspects of education that are difficult to measure directly, but they contribute towards general problem solving and reasoning ability.


written by jwray  | 1 week ago | CH
 0  | flag spam (0)